Should 69传媒 Be Allowed to Eat in Class? Here's What Teachers Have to Say (Opinion)

Save to favorites
Print

Copy URL

Opinion Contributor, Education Week

Larry Ferlazzo is an English and social studies teacher at Luther Burbank High School in Sacramento, Calif.

The new question-of-the-week is:

What are your recommendations for how teachers should handle students eating in class?

Our students often seem like they are always hungry鈥攕ome due to their families鈥� economic conditions, some because they got up too late to eat breakfast, and some because their growing bodies just need to eat a lot.

I鈥檓 a high school teacher and always have crackers and other nonsugary snacks in my cupboard. My students know if they are really hungry, they can always get something from there and eat it inside or outside the classroom, depending on the time and the weather. My food鈥檚 availability has hardly ever been abused.

Also, except during most of the last school year when our district had a mask mandate, I鈥檝e always explained to students that eating in class can be distracting. However, I also tell students that if we are working in small groups, and if they are able to focus and not make a mess, that they can eat their own snacks during that time. This rule has seemed to work well.

Today, let鈥檚 hear how four other educators handle the 鈥渆ating in class鈥� question.

Michael Pershan, Deborah Offner, Ashley Kearney, and Vivian Micolta Simmons have contributed responses.

No, With Exceptions

Michael Pershan is a math teacher and writer in N.Y.C. He is the author of the book Teaching Math With Examples:

I tell students鈥攆rom 3^rd to 12^th grades鈥攖hat they can鈥檛 eat in my class. I explain it鈥檚 because they need their hands for writing. If they protest, I shrug and explain that it鈥檚 a school rule.

I鈥檓 actually not totally sure if it is a rule at my school, but I think it should be. I have learned that there is no such thing as silent eating. Food is generally crunchy, slimy, or sticky, and often, it鈥檚 two out of the three. And, like in the children鈥檚 book If You Give a Mouse a Cookie, it鈥檚 never just the food. If you let a student eat a granola bar, they鈥檙e going to ask to get a drink. If they get a drink, they鈥檒l spill it on the desk. To clean up the spill, they鈥檒l need a paper towel. But if there are no towels in the bathroom. 鈥�

So, yes, I am an annoying hardliner about eating in class.

And yet, even as I write this, I can鈥檛 help but think of all the times I鈥檝e made exceptions to this rule. At summer school, when the train was delayed and the program was providing breakfast, which the student missed. Last year, when a serious and conscientious high school senior asked if she could finish her lunch in the first few minutes of my calculus class. And the many times when a homeroom teacher hands a 3^rd grader a pretzel rod right before my math lesson.

When I ask students to put their snacks away, I sometimes encourage them to put it on my desk, which both removes the item while keeping it visible, reassuring them that the food hasn鈥檛 gone anywhere, and they鈥檒l get it back eventually. I tell students to take one last bite, and often, then they sneak in a second one, which I鈥檒l pretend not to see.

Teaching is I think often like this. We need to have reasonable rules and clear standards so we can focus on learning while avoiding endless haggling and negotiation about our expectations. At the same time, we are dealing with children, and a certain amount of compassion and flexibility is called for.

Some educators may let students eat in class, seeing it as a case where flexibility should take precedence over the learning environment. But I say that 鈥渘o food鈥� is a valuable rule to have and enforce, as much as we reasonably can.

Yes, 鈥榃ithin Certain Parameters鈥�

Deborah Offner is a clinical psychologist and former dean of students who has worked in schools and colleges for 25 years. She is the author of Educators as First Responders: A Teacher鈥檚 Guide to Adolescent Development and Mental Health, Grades 6-12:

At the end of my first lecture of the semester, a college student approached me sheepishly.

鈥泪鈥檓 so sorry,鈥� she said. 鈥泪鈥檓 not sure if you noticed that I was eating during class. ... I had field hockey practice right before, and this was the first chance I had to eat.鈥�

鈥泪 诲颈诲苍鈥檛 notice, actually,鈥� I said, 鈥渁nd it鈥檚 totally fine.鈥� Of course you must have been hungry after your practice. Not a problem!鈥�

My student鈥檚 intuitive regard for the formality of our classroom environment was one of the things that distinguished her from the middle school students with whom I鈥檇 spent that morning. And the first time her snack came to my attention鈥攐r, I suspect, anyone else鈥檚鈥攚as when she announced it to me. In a class of 40 students, a 19-year-old鈥檚 stealthy protein bar consumption doesn鈥檛 hit a professor鈥檚 radar. Of course, a 4th grader scarfing down a yogurt parfait during math鈥攜ogurt dribbling onto their desk, granola spilling onto the floor鈥攊s another story.

Despite the potential for both distraction and mess, students may need to eat in your classroom for a variety of reasons, most importantly, because hungry students can鈥檛 concentrate on learning! Some students skip breakfast at home and/or at schools where it鈥檚 offered due to tight morning schedules or not having an appetite first thing in the morning. Many fewer students miss lunch, though this happens, too. Finally, growing children and teenagers often need nutritional 鈥渞einforcements鈥� between meals because, as most teachers and parents know, some of them are simply hungry all the time! My general advice is that eating in the classroom should be allowed, within certain parameters, and with plenty of paper towels and trash cans nearby.

Here are some guidelines for handling student eating in your classroom. Like most issues, they vary according to grade level.

For younger students (5th grade and below) establish a classroomwide snack time. This is more important in the morning, though you may want to add an afternoon snack time, depending on the time span between lunchtime and the end of the school day. Taking time (10-15 minutes) to eat together ensures that students have the opportunity to eat if they鈥檙e hungry. It allows you to manage noise and mess collectively, directing students to dispose of trash and clean off their desks all at once. And a bonus is built-in social, movement, and relaxation time that allows students to recharge between lessons.

It鈥檚 optimal (though by no means guaranteed) that your school provides classroom snacks, for equity鈥檚 sake, as some students鈥� families don鈥檛 have consistent or reliable access to food. If you are not able to provide snacks, have students bring them from home. If your classroom budget allows, you can also offer parents the option of purchasing snacks you order in bulk, rather than sending their own food. The upside of this add-on is that if a subset of parents report it would be a financial hardship for them to provide a snack, you can 鈥渃omp鈥� their children鈥檚 food without distinguishing them from those who are able to pay.

For older students (6th grade and above), consider allowing students to eat at their own initiative during class, as long as they adhere to specific guidelines and stipulations. These include the following:

Eating is allowed as long as it鈥檚 not overly messy, noisy, or disruptive, and students clean up! Place more than one trash can in the room so it鈥檚 easy for students to dispose of waste. Insist that eating does not distract the student or their classmates.

Remember, older students should be able to engage in a contract of sorts regarding a privilege that鈥檚 important to them. If one of them strays, the pressure of the group will bring them back on board. The agreement is simple: If they want the freedoms of my college student, they must aspire to act more like her!

鈥楢n Opportunity to Build Relationships鈥�

Ashley Kearney is an award-winning educator focusing on systemic changes that can support the whole child:

There are various reasons why a student may eat in class. Assuming there is not a school rule, which may need to be examined if it exists, teachers can use students鈥� frequent need to eat in their class as an opportunity to build relationships while also educating one another.

I taught all boys at one point, and one of the best things that I could do, taking allergies into consideration, was set up a PB&J and water table. 69传媒 would remind me about the grocery store run or bring bread to restock. There were certain times it was appropriate to get a snack and water that 诲颈诲苍鈥檛 require asking me and doing so during natural pauses within the broader structures of the class and honoring the time necessary for tasks. This was in high school where mutual understanding and strong relationships were built. I鈥檇 argue that it helped to form deeper relationships of trust and respect with some students.

Set up a snack bar and use it as an opportunity to practice community norms. Learn about the different foods from different cultures represented in the class, nutritious foods, or even just the impact of certain foods on the brain. My view is that everything does not have to be seen as a problem. Instead, it might be an opportunity.

鈥楧esignate a Snack Time鈥�

Vivian Micolta Simmons was born in Colombia and has been in the United States for seven years. She has been a teacher for 14 years and is currently working as a ESL/DLI lead teacher for the Iredell-Statesville schools in North Carolina:

Honestly, I have never had an issue with students eating in class as long as we set a time for it. I get it; I have gotten hungry at random times during the day and I will be against prohibiting a student from eating in class.

Think about our students coming from Central and South America. In Colombia, our schedule for instruction time ran from 7 a.m. to 10 a.m. Right at 10 a.m., we would stop for a recess (eat a snack and play), then go from 10:30 a.m. to12:30 p.m., stop for lunch, and then end our academic day.

It was a shock for me when I first got to the U.S.A. and I had to teach straight from 7:00 until 11 or 12, with no snack break in between. Or other times where my lunchtime will fall right at 10:30 a.m. (I was not ready for lunch at that time.)

As long as we designate a snack time in class (no matter the age of the students) and we are aware of possible allergies among our group of students, I see no problem with students eating in class. I want to eat, too!

Thanks to Michael, Deborah, Ashley, and Vivian for contributing their thoughts!

Consider contributing a question to be answered in a future post. You can send one to me at lferlazzo@epe.org. When you send it in, let me know if I can use your real name if it鈥檚 selected or if you鈥檇 prefer remaining anonymous and have a pseudonym in mind.

You can also contact me on Twitter at .

Education Week has published a collection of posts from this blog, along with new material, in an e-book form. It鈥檚 titled .

Just a reminder; you can subscribe and receive updates from this blog via (The RSS feed for this blog, and for all Ed Week articles, has been changed by the new redesign鈥攏ew ones are not yet available). And if you missed any of the highlights from the first 10 years of this blog, you can see a categorized list below.

I am also creating a .

The opinions expressed in Classroom Q&A With Larry Ferlazzo are strictly those of the author(s) and do not reflect the opinions or endorsement of Editorial Projects in Education, or any of its publications.