69传媒

Student Achievement

IQ Study Weighs Genes,Environment

By Linda Jacobson 鈥 September 10, 2003 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Children growing up in middle-class and wealthy families may not benefit much from all those classical-music CDs, interactive books, and exclusive preschool programs meant to boost a young child鈥檚 brainpower. But early intervention in the home and in the classroom can make a big difference for a child born into extreme poverty, according to a soon-to-be-published study.

Led by Eric Turkheimer, a psychologist at the University of Virginia in Charlottesville, the study concludes that while genetic makeup explains most of the differences in IQ for children in wealthier families, environment鈥攁nd not genes鈥攎akes a bigger difference for minority children in low-income homes.

Specifically, what researchers call 鈥渉eritability"鈥攖he degree to which genes influence IQ鈥攚as significantly lower for poor families, 0.1 on a scale of zero to 1, than it was for those at the higher end of the income spectrum, for whom it was 0.72.

鈥淥nce you鈥檙e put into an adequate environment, your genes start to take over,鈥 Mr. Turkheimer said in an interview last week. But in poor environments, 鈥済enes don鈥檛 have that ability.鈥

Mr. Turkheimer said his findings do not back up any particular program or intervention strategy. But the study, which is to be published in the November issue of the journal Psychological Science, does suggest that spending on Head Start and other high-quality programs for children of low socioeconomic status are worthwhile, he said.

鈥淢oney spent on improving environments is best spent on improving the worst environments,鈥 he said.

By the same token, he said, spending money in schools where students are already doing well 鈥渋sn鈥檛 going to have the same bang for the buck as taking schools that are very bad and making them OK.鈥

Looking at Twins

To conduct the research, Mr. Turkheimer and his colleagues analyzed data from the National Collaborative Perinatal Project, a study conducted by the federal government from 1959 to 1974.

The sample included close to 50,000 pregnant women, mostly African- American and living near or below the poverty line. Because the sample was so large, more than 600 pairs of twins were born.

Seven years later, the researchers administered the Wechsler Intelligence Scale for Children to 319 pairs of the twins, with 114 of them being identical twins and the rest fraternal. Those test scores were used to estimate the children鈥檚 IQ levels.

Looking at the differences in traits between identical and fraternal twins allows researchers to isolate characteristics based on genetics. But such research has been limited, because few twin studies include children from poor families.

The sizable sample of twins in the University of Virginia study, combined with new statistical models for studying the effects of socioeconomic status, allowed Mr. Turkheimer to arrive at his results.

鈥淎lthough there is much that remains to be understood, our study and the ones that have preceded it have begun to converge on the hypothesis that the developmental forces at work in poor environments are qualitatively different than those at work in adequate ones,鈥 according to an advance copy of Mr. Turkheimer鈥檚 Psychological Science article.

Revisiting The Bell Curve

Mr. Turkheimer鈥檚 research revisits what he and the other primary author of the article, Irving I. Gottesman, a psychology professor at the University of Minnesota Medical School in Minneapolis, call 鈥渢he fractious history of scientific investigations of the heritability of intelligence.鈥

A key moment in that history occurred in 1994 when the book called The Bell Curve was published. In it, authors Richard J. Herrnstein and Charles Murray suggested that genes explain most of the differences in cognitive ability.

By offering support for the notion that African-Americans were intellectually inferior to whites and other races鈥攁nd that education or other interventions were largely powerless to change that鈥攖he book drew sharp criticism and charges of racism.

Reached by e-mail last week, Mr. Murray, a political scientist who is now a senior fellow at the American Enterprise Institute, a Washington think tank, said he was not ready to comment on Mr. Turkheimer鈥檚 research and 鈥渘eeded more time to digest鈥 the findings.

Krista Kafer, a senior policy analyst at the Washington-based Heritage Foundation, said she thought using the new research to justify spending on Head Start and other programs was 鈥渢oo much of a leap.鈥

鈥淚t鈥檚 using science for advocacy,鈥 she said, adding that she could use the same findings to argue in favor of giving low-income families school choice.

鈥楢 Wake-Up Call鈥

Others welcomed what they see as the implications of the study.

The new study confirms 鈥渢he philosophy that experience and environment account for a lot of the variabilities鈥 in children, said Jeffrey Seltzer, a child psychologist working with the Montgomery County, Md., school district鈥檚 Head Start and pre-K programs. 鈥淚t鈥檚 great that they have research now to back this up, but this is certainly the assumption that I鈥檝e been working under.鈥

Jane Knitzer, the acting director of the National Center for Children in Poverty, located at Columbia University, said that the study 鈥渃hallenges the myth that investing in social programs is a waste of money.鈥

She added that while the concept of 鈥渦niversal鈥 preschool for young children is an important development, the research shows that special attention needs to be paid to enriching experiences for the poorest children.

鈥淚n this current fiscal climate that we鈥檙e in, I think it鈥檚 a wake- up call to be cautious about what we unravel,鈥 she said.

Mr. Turkheimer added that it is important for more researchers to 鈥渋nclude very poor children in analyses of genes and environment.鈥

And he noted that all of the mandated achievement testing being conducted in schools could be used for more than just holding schools accountable for results. 鈥淚t鈥檚 a fabulous research base,鈥 he said.

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Special Education Webinar
Don鈥檛 Count Them Out: Dyscalculia Support from PreK-Career
Join Dr. Elliott and Dr. Wall as they empower educators to support students with dyscalculia to envision successful careers and leadership roles.
Content provided by 
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Well-Being Webinar
Improve School Culture and Engage 69传媒: Archery鈥檚 Critical Role in Education
Changing lives one arrow at a time. Find out why administrators and principals are raving about archery in their schools.
Content provided by 
School Climate & Safety Webinar Engaging Every Student: How to Address Absenteeism and Build Belonging
Gain valuable insights and practical solutions to address absenteeism and build a more welcoming and supportive school environment.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide 鈥 elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Student Achievement Spotlight Spotlight on Addressing Learning Gaps
This Spotlight will help you explore strategies to address gaps, accelerate learning, support students' overall well-being, and more.
Student Achievement 69传媒 Scores Fall to New Low on NAEP, Fueled by Declines for Struggling 69传媒
A third of 8th graders and 40 percent of 4th graders did not meet a "basic" reading level.
8 min read
Illustration of a ruler tilted downward with books, a plus symbol and a number 1 starting to slide off. There is an educator pushing the number one in an effort to keep things behind it from sliding off.
Gina Tomko/Education Week + Getty
Student Achievement From Our Research Center Learning Recovery Has Stalled. What Should 69传媒 Do Next?
69传媒 are still not fully caught up, educators said in a new survey.
4 min read
A group of high school girls work together to solve an algebra problem during their precalculus class.
A group of high school girls work together to solve an algebra problem during their precalculus class. Nearly 4 in 10 educators said the level of unfinished learning in secondary math was 鈥渟evere鈥 or 鈥渧ery severe,鈥 a new survey shows.
Allison Shelley for All4Ed
Student Achievement Interactive Boys Are Falling Behind Girls in School. See How
The data are clear: Girls, on average, find more success at school than boys.