69“«Ć½

Opinion
Student Well-Being Opinion

Why Iā€™m Tired of ā€˜Gritā€™

By James R. Delisle ā€” February 09, 2016 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Rory Storm and the Hurricanes were a band from Liverpool, England, who went to Hamburg, Germanyā€™s Cavern Club in 1960 to make their mark on the emerging pop-music scene. They didnā€™t do well, releasing only two singles, neither of which made the Top 40 charts. But Rory Storm and the Hurricanes had an opening act that did a tad better. They were named the Beatles. Both played the same club, alternating six 90-minute performances each night for months. But only one band became a household name, while the other became a mere asterisk in the British Invasion.

If you believe Malcolm Gladwellā€”he of the mindset that 10,000 hours of practice (ā€œgritā€) will make even the biggest musical sowā€™s ear into a silk purseā€”both the Beatles and Rory Storm and the Hurricanes should have been equally successful. But they werenā€™t, causing me to question Gladwellā€™s assertion in his 2008 book Outliers: The Story of Success that the Beatles would not have become the Beatles without the Hamburg experience. What distinguished these two bands? Iā€™m guessing that the Beatles, as individuals, had something innate that Rory and his buddies didnā€™t possess: musical genius that was enhanced by practice, but not determined by it.

BRIC ARCHIVE

The concept of ā€œgritā€ has given both pop psychologists and those who discount the importance of genetics yet one more mantra on which to hang their pseudo-theoretical hats. Dismissing the role and importance of innate talents and abilities as true determinants of success, Gladwell chooses ā€œpractice, practice, practiceā€ as the biggest driver of achievement. I half expected him to dedicate his book to Watty Piper, the author of The Little Engine That Could, as his views carry the same academic weight as that childrenā€™s classic.

Why am I so tired of grit? Here are three reasons:

The concept of 'grit' has given both pop psychologists and those who discount the importance of genetics yet one more mantra on which to hang their pseudo-theoretical hats.

  1. As a concept, grit offers simplistic solutions to the complex topic of achievement. Every human being succeeds or fails for a multitude of reasons. Sometimes we donā€™t try hard enough. Sometimes weā€™re just not interested in the topic weā€™re supposed to learn. And sometimes we are in an environment that makes learning difficult, as when we havenā€™t eaten breakfast before school started, or when ā€œacting smartā€ is a social stigma thatā€™s not worth the hassle to endure. But with just a bit of grit, everything is solved as long as we think the right way and rise up after we fall. By not considering the context of the learning process, the degree of interest in the topic under study, or the life circumstances that have powerful control over both our achievement and our emotions, the concept of grit dismisses all too casually some of the most important factors that pave the road to success.
  2. Grit relegates the role of genetics and innate abilities to an afterthought. Proponents of grit pay a passing nod to the fact that some people are better at things than others. However, whether they want to admit it or not, some people are intellectual superstars, while others struggle to learn; some are Derek-Jeter-quality baseball players while others canā€™t make it beyond the Little League; and some musicians do become the Beatles, while othersā€”well, just recall Rory Storm and the Hurricanes. By discounting the vital role of genetically endowed abilities in virtually every human dimensionā€”academics, the arts, athleticsā€”advocates of grit are ignoring a century or more of psychology that points to the importance of innate abilities and talents.
  3. Grit attempts to equate unequals as equals. In 1784, Thomas Jefferson proposed the establishment of schools where ā€œboys of best geniusā€ from impoverished backgrounds would get an advanced education in Greek, Latin, geography, and higher mathematics. After a yearā€™s trial at these schools, the most intelligent boys were to be retained for six more years of education, and the ā€œresidue dismissed.ā€

Granted, Jeffersonā€™s choice of the word ā€œresidueā€ is inappropriate, and his omission of females is patently offensive, by 21st-century standards, but his mission was clear: to identify and educate intelligent children in ways that respected their fine minds.

See also

Read James Delisle's Commentary on differentiation:
BRIC ARCHIVE
Chris Whetzel for Education Week
Teaching Opinion Differentiation Doesn't Work
James R. Delisle, January 6, 2015
5 min read

Nowadays, the mere mention of educating gifted and advanced students separately from others elicits cries of elitism, racism, classism, and too many other ā€œismsā€ to name. But if you just had a little grit, then everyone could be gifted, right? Wrong. Jefferson was on point when he wrote that ā€œthere is nothing more unequal than the equal treatment of unequal people.ā€

Sad to say, the National Assessment of Educational Progress, or NAEP, often dubbed ā€œthe nationā€™s report card,ā€ is working to include measures of grit on tests beginning in 2017. And just recently, the U.S. Department of Education awarded three school districts and a charter school network $2 million in grants to help students improve the ā€œsofter skillsā€ of grit that accompany learning. My prediction? Five years from now, grit notwithstanding, some kids will still be smarter, more athletic, and more artistic than other kids. Iā€™ll bet my Beatles record collection on it.

A version of this article appeared in the February 10, 2016 edition of Education Week as Iā€™m Tired of ā€˜Gritā€™

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Artificial Intelligence Webinar
AI and Educational Leadership: Driving Innovation and Equity
Discover how to leverage AI to transform teaching, leadership, and administration. Network with experts and learn practical strategies.
Content provided by 
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School Climate & Safety Webinar
Investing in Success: Leading a Culture of Safety and Support
Content provided by 
Assessment K-12 Essentials Forum Making Competency-Based Learning a Reality
Join this free virtual event to hear from educators and experts working to implement competency-based education.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide ā€” elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Student Well-Being Student Journalists Want to Cover Politics. Not Everyone Agrees They Should
Student journalists are grappling with controversial topicsā€”a lesson in democracy that's becoming increasingly at risk for pushback.
7 min read
Illustration of a paper airplane made from a newspaper.
DigitalVision Vectors
Student Well-Being Opinion 3 Things You Need to Know About Absenteeism
We studied the data from more than 1.5 million students. Hereā€™s are some overlooked insights to boost attendance.
Todd Rogers, Emily Bailard & Mikia Manley
4 min read
Scattered school desks seen from above, some with red x's on them signifying absences.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week and iStock/Getty Images
Student Well-Being SEL Has Become Politicized. 69“«Ć½ Are Embracing It Anyway
Eighty-three percent of principals report that their schools use an SEL curriculum or program.
5 min read
Image of positive movement when attending to a student's well-being is a component.
Dmitrii_Guzhanin/iStock/Getty and Laura Baker/Education Week
Student Well-Being 69“«Ć½ Don't Want to Talk About Politics, Either
The election is occurring at a time when many schools are discouraged from having tough conversations in class.
6 min read
Viewers gather to watch a debate between Democratic presidential nominee Vice President Kamala Harris and Republican presidential nominee former President Donald Trump at the Angry Elephant Bar and Grill, Tuesday, Sept. 10, 2024, in San Antonio.
Viewers gather to watch a debate between Democratic presidential nominee Vice President Kamala Harris and Republican presidential nominee former President Donald Trump at the Angry Elephant Bar and Grill, Sept. 10, 2024, in San Antonio. Researchers say students are more reluctant to talk politics this election cycle.
Eric Gay/AP