One of the most difficult tests facing schools this fall is how to pull off widespread intervention and assistance for students who begin the 2020-21 school year with learning loss.鈥����������������������
The challenge is not a new one. American classrooms have always been heterogeneous, serving students of vastly different backgrounds. But those gaps will be intensified due to the disparities in access to health care, the internet, and robust teaching wrought by COVID-19 since last March.鈥�
Historically, efforts to 鈥渃atch kids up鈥� have been disappointing, with so-called turnaround programs and even much-heralded approaches like Response to Intervention producing mixed results in practice.
Still, researchers and educators emphasize, there are ways to mitigate the damage that will inevitably be done to students as the pandemic rages on. Many are rooted in centuries-old practices and common sense but require considerable planning and finesse to make them work.鈥�
All the approaches depend on having a few key elements already in place: a solid curriculum; a commitment to grade-level teaching; and strategies to engage students, including tracking them down and contacting them if they aren鈥檛 showing up for remote or hybrid learning.
By far the most effective intervention for students who have fallen behind鈥攊ntensive tutoring鈥攈as high start-up costs. While there are ways to lower some of them, severe budget cuts could put it out of reach for all but a fraction of districts. Indeed, the federal government鈥檚 feckless response to the pandemic means that leaders can鈥檛 count on additional help to defray the cost of doing more for students who will return to school with less.鈥�
For this installment on how to address students鈥� learning losses, Education Week interviewed two dozen researchers, teachers, and principals, and reviewed hundreds of pages of empirical studies and planning documents to identify interventions that are well supported by research鈥攁nd other approaches that are unlikely to move the needle.鈥�
Sixth in a series of eight installments.
These times are unprecedented. Through eight installments, Education Week explores the steps administrators need to take to ensure the safety of students and faculty.
How We Go Back to School is supported in part by the Chan Zuckerberg Initiative.
The pieces in this part of our series all come with a caveat: They are extrapolated from studies conducted during traditional, in-person schooling. Superintendents and principals bear the difficult responsibility not only of deciding which of these options are technically and financially feasible, but also adjusting them creatively to the realities of fully remote or hybrid schooling.鈥�
鈥擲tephen Sawchuk
Downloadable: A Guide to Help 69传媒 Catch Up
FOUNDATION
Interventions and services aimed at restoring lost learning are most likely to succeed when schools are layering them on top of a solid academic foundation.
That means districts should prioritize several things first: grade-level teaching for all students, a way to track each student鈥檚 whereabouts, a curriculum synched across schools and delivery methods (in-person and remote), plenty of uninterrupted teaching time, and schedules that benefit the students most likely to need additional help.
Deep Dive: COVID-19鈥檚 Harm to Learning Is Inevitable. How 69传媒 Can Start to Address It
CLOSE TRACKING
The first step in an effective intervention is identifying the students who need extra help. Early-warning systems can be interwoven with the individual teacher-led gauges of student learning. These systems track indicators like attendance and quarter grades throughout the year and identify students who are slipping and need extra academic or social-emotional assistance.
But districts must be creative to adjust some of the indicators in these systems to the realities of remote or hybrid learning鈥攅specially as things like attendance take on new meaning.
TUTORING
Study after study identifies intensive, one-on-one or one-to-two tutoring as the most effective way to help students who are falling behind in their learning to catch up. The challenge for districts is figuring out how to pay for this expensive approach, and how to make it translate in a remote setting.
Research suggests that using paraprofessionals and volunteers can be effective. Beginning with slightly larger tutoring groups may also be an approach to consider.
Deep Dive: High-Dosage Tutoring Is Effective, But Expensive. Ideas for Making It Work
EXTENDING TIME
Extending learning time in creative ways, such as weeklong 鈥渁cademies鈥� during spring or fall breaks or Saturday sessions, show promise for significant learning gains. These so-called acceleration academies are showing real promise in a group of districts in Massachusetts.
In targeted, small group environments, teachers use research-based strategies to improve students鈥� foundational skills and content and to build strong relationships. Districts will have to take the lead in administering and planning for the extra teaching.
Deep Dive: 69传媒 Lost Time and Learning in the Pandemic. What 鈥楢cceleration鈥� Can Do to Help
