69传媒

Includes updates and/or revisions.

As the Obama administration鈥檚 signature education improvement program moves toward its close, U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan is recognizing four states for leading the Race to the Top: Delaware, Hawaii, North Carolina, and Tennessee.

New released Wednesday from the U.S. Department of Education showcase just how far the 12 state-level have come as they seek to deliver on the promises that won them, collectively, $4 billion.

Yet even with billions of dollars and the political cover that came with winning a grant, Race to the Top states are still struggling mightily with an issue that鈥檚 vexing most other states as well: how to improve teacher evaluations and the profession as a whole.

The 2013-14 school year is, for the most part, the final year of implementation for the four-year program that has become one of the Obama administration鈥檚 most important domestic policy initiatives. And the program will certainly be a key piece of Education Secretary Arne Duncan鈥檚 K-12 legacy.

A 鈥楻ising Star鈥�

鈥淭eacher evaluations were arguably the most important and far-reaching policy change to come out of [Race to the Top] and states are having serious trouble delivering,鈥� said Andy Smarick, a partner at the consulting firm Bellwether Education Partners who has been studying Race to the Top implementation. 鈥淚f this doesn鈥檛 work out, it will hurt the long-term legacy of RTTT鈥攊t鈥檒l be another sign that the feds can get states and districts to do things but they can鈥檛 make them do it well.鈥�

The 2010 grant contest asked states to devise their boldest plans to improve education in four areas: standards and assessments, data systems, teacher evaluations, and low-performing schools.

Based on this third round of annual progress reports, Hawaii鈥攐nce in danger of losing its grant over teacher-evaluation problems鈥攚as highlighted by federal officials as a 鈥渞ising star鈥� while Tennessee got praise for being 鈥渕ost improved鈥� in terms of boosting student achievement. Mr. Duncan praised North Carolina and Delaware for their teacher-improvement efforts.

And although the department says it鈥檚 too early to definitively link student-achievement results to Race to the Top, federal officials point out that the majority of winning states were in the top quartile in reading improvement on the most recent results from the National Assessment of Educational Progress.

鈥淲e are starting to see these investments we made three years ago enter the classroom,鈥� Mr. Duncan told reporters on a March 18 call in advance of the reports鈥� release, noting that these improvement efforts are ongoing despite some 鈥渃ontention and chaos鈥� in state legislatures. (The Common Core State Standards and new teacher evaluations, in particular, are hot-button issues.)

Implementation Struggles

All winners are struggling to implement big promises to overhaul the teaching profession in their states. Mostly, they are struggling to implement new evaluation systems linked to student growth on test scores. But the problems go beyond just designing and putting new evaluations into practice.

New evaluation systems in Florida and Delaware, for example, resulted in very few meaningful differences in teacher ratings. In essence, nearly every teacher in those states was deemed effective based on those evaluations.

Massachusetts is making only 鈥渓imited progress鈥� in establishing a new professional-development system, the department found. Ohio has reported 鈥渕inimal interest鈥� among its districts in several initiatives designed to improve the equitable distribution of teachers, such as a new exit survey to study teacher attrition. And the District of Columbia, which was included in the state-level competition, was found to have calculated some teacher ratings incorrectly.

Winners with the biggest challenges overall, based on the reports, seem to be the District of Columbia, Florida, Georgia, and Maryland.

Georgia is in the deepest trouble. The state is in the midst of forfeiting $9 million of its grant over unfulfilled teacher-evaluation promises, and is criticized in its progress report over 鈥渃oncerns about the overall strategic planning, evaluation, and project management for that system.鈥�

The District of Columbia also is struggling with turning around its low-performing schools, while Maryland is experiencing significant delays implementing common-core-related programs, according to the reports.

For their part, Maryland officials say they are already taking steps to correct problems revealed in the reports. The state has, for example, contracted with a vendor to begin developing resources for a new instructional toolkit, which will provide an online collection of standards-aligned materials for educators.

Long 鈥楾o-Do鈥� Lists

Even though much of the Race to the Top work is supposed to be completed, some states still have lengthy to-do lists, including Florida, which has experienced big delays in implementing common-core-aligned interim and final assessments. In addition, New York had only spent 35 percent of its $700 million in winnings as of September 2013, in part because of big delays launching a new data portal.

鈥淣o state is doing this perfectly. Every state is working hard. We do think certain states are further ahead than others,鈥� Mr. Duncan said.

Because of implementation delays, the Education Department is in the process of approving 鈥渘o-cost鈥� extensions that allow states a fifth year to finish their work and spend their money. Eleven of the 12 winners, so far, have applied for this extra time. The exception is Hawaii, the state that caught the education policy world by surprise when it won the grant in the first place.

With a nod to the future, Hawaii Superintendent of Education Kathryn Matayoshi said last week: 鈥淎s we head into the final months of the grant, we continue our commitment to put into place systems and practices that will keep our students successful in college, careers and community long after the grant ends. Race to the Top was an important step in the transformation of our public school system and we are staying the course.鈥�

Race to the Top Grant Winners