69ý

Opinion
Social Studies Opinion

A Year After Oct. 7, Silence Isn’t an Option for Teachers

Two guardrails for teaching about the Israel-Hamas war offer a path
By Eli Gottlieb — October 07, 2024 5 min read
A small plant signifying hope grows out of a crack in the pavement, casting  shadow of the large tree it will grow into. Candles burn in remembrance.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Events overseas rarely impact education in America. The war in Gaza is an. Its social significance and the extent to which about it provide a glimpse of education’s future. For America’s teachers, 10/7 and its aftermath are much more than and the struggle over how best to talk about them with students presents a huge challenge. But there are steps educators can take.

A year has passed since Hamas commandos invaded southern Israel, killing 1,200 citizens, tourists and foreign workers, and taking more than . Eyewitness testimony, physical evidence, and GoPro video shared live on social media by the perpetrators show that the brutal attack included execution of civilians, sexual violence, mutilation of corpses, and hostages paraded to cheering crowds in Gaza.

Israel’s military response was swift and ferocious. According to , a year of fighting has left more than 41,000 Gazans dead, 95,000 injured, 1.9 million displaced, and 60 percent of Gaza’s buildings destroyed. Neither in Israel nor in Gaza seems interested in a ceasefire. With Iran now targeting Israeli civilians rather than via her proxies in the —in Gaza, in Lebanon, and in Yemen—and Israel responding accordingly, the prospect of peace seems even further away. 97 of the hostages abducted on 10/7 remain captive in Gaza, including 4 American citizens.

, and student activists in the United States mobilized to justify Hamas’ actions and to their cause. Although media attention has focused on the turmoil in higher education, K-12, too, has been affected. At , student activists have organized walkouts, teach-ins, and marches in support of Palestinian liberation and against U.S. military support for Israel. At in New York City, rioting students stormed hallways, heading for a teacher’s classroom, after she posted a picture of herself on Facebook holding an “I stand with Israel” sign. Arab students at in Washington filed a lawsuit , claiming they were being treated differently from Black and Asian students.

Curriculum has been affected, too. Two social studies teachers at in New Jersey were investigated after parents complained that their to 11th graders referred to the 10/7 massacres as “clashes” in which Hamas was able to “break out” of Gaza. In , Calif., a parent sued the school district to turn over a 9th grade curriculum that included lesson plans criticizing Israel and disproportionately relying on fringe views of Jewish anti-Zionists. Local teachers’ union president Matt Meyer attributed the controversy to interfering parents trying to “micromanage our educators.”

So, as we acknowledge the first anniversary of a day in which , a war in which roughly , and a year in which attacks outside of Israel and Gaza on Jewish Americans increased percent and on Muslim Americans percent in just a few months, what should public schools teach young Americans about the war or about the broader context of the Jewish and Palestinian peoples’ respective struggles for self-determination on land to which both consider themselves indigenous?

For many teachers, the answer is: Nothing. In these polarized times, why risk the wrath of litigious parents, conflict-avoidant administrators, and activist board members by And fear is not the only motive for avoiding it. Teachers can plead ignorance, arguing that Israeli-Palestinian history is so complex, they’re unqualified to teach it. Or they can recuse themselves for almost the opposite reason, namely, that they identify so much with one side in the conflict that they cannot teach anything about it without bias.

But in education, as in law, ignorance is no defense. And if you can’t teach something that matters to you without bias, then perhaps you should consider a different profession. When get their news from , it’s a teacher’s job to engage them in informed, civil discussion of what is happening and why.

Silence isn’t an option. What is?

I’ve no magic bullet. But I can suggest two guardrails to help teachers step up, stay true to their vocation, and respect the sensitivities of students and parents: humanity and humility.

To teach the Israel-Hamas war with humanity is to ensure those murdered and abducted on 10/7 are neither erased from history nor discounted as fair game in a noble battle of oppressed versus oppressor. It is also to acknowledge the horror suffered by Gazans in the ensuing war. It is to resist glib statements about suffering “on both sides,” which lump together victims of different kinds of violence, undertaken with different kinds of intent, and resulting in different scales of impact. As Americans know all too well, can be used to justify the indefensible.

It is also to teach with due care and consideration for students and teachers who have personal ties to the conflict, whether ethnic, religious, or familial. To check whether you pass the humanity test, ask yourself whether what you’re planning to teach can comfortably accommodate the facts I listed in my second and third paragraphs. If it can accommodate only some but not others, try again.

By humility, I mean with due recognition of how complex Middle East history and geopolitics are and the unreliability of the accounts of both that most students encounter. Humility does not mean granting equal airtime to all opinions or to those shouted loudest. It means, on the contrary, modeling critical thinking, distinguishing fact from opinion, and sensitizing students. It also means being open to learning something new and being surprised rather than confirming bias.

These guardrails are not a curriculum. They are an educational stance. Some teachers might express humanity through thoughtful commemorations of individual school-age Israelis and Palestinians who lost their lives this year. Some might focus their efforts on humility by fact-checking contested accounts of the events of 10/7 and the ensuing war in Gaza, or by inviting students to share what they know and feel about them, giving space to lesser heard voices and perspectives.

What matters is that teachers hold themselves accountable to their educational mission and not be cowed into silence. The moment requires it. And America’s students need it.

Related Tags:

Events

School & District Management Webinar Crafting Outcomes-Based Contracts That Work for Everyone
Discover the power of outcomes-based contracts and how they can drive student achievement.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
Harnessing AI to Address Chronic Absenteeism in 69ý
Learn how AI can help your district improve student attendance and boost academic outcomes.
Content provided by 
School & District Management Webinar EdMarketer Quick Hit: What’s Trending among K-12 Leaders?
What issues are keeping K-12 leaders up at night? Join us for EdMarketer Quick Hit: What’s Trending among K-12 Leaders?

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Social Studies 'If We Don’t Vote, Nothing Is Going to Change': First-Time Voters Report Back
69ý at this Wyoming high school share their experience of voting for the first time.
6 min read
Arapahoe Charter School seniors Alissah C'Hair, Kenya Rhodes, Dontae Antelope, Esperanza Sittingeagle, Zona Roskowske, and Kieden Birdshead stand for a group photo after casting their votes on Nov. 5, 2024, in Arapahoe, Wy.
Arapahoe Charter School seniors Alissah C'Hair, Kenya Rhodes, Dontae Antelope, Esperanza Sittingeagle, Zona Roskowske, and Kieden Birdshead stand for a group photo after casting their votes on Nov. 5, 2024, in Arapahoe, Wy.
Carl Cote for Education Week
Social Studies Download What Is Social Studies Literacy? How Educators In the Field Teach 69ý
The sources students consult, the kinds of arguments they make, differ from history to economics to geography.
1 min read
Image of a bookshelf.
Luoman/E+
Social Studies Inside the Class Where 69ý Talk About Abortion, Trump v. Harris, and More
A Maine high school has piloted a new class called Election Year, where students dive deep into campaign politics.
8 min read
EdTech Megan Leddy holds up her laptop to show an Electoral College map to students Sabrina Conary and Asher Clark during a discussion in the Election Year course at Mount Desert Island High School in Bar Harbor, Maine, on Oct. 22, 2024.
Teaching assistant Megan Leddy holds up her laptop to show an Electoral College map to students Sabrina Conary and Asher Clark during a discussion in the Election Year course at Mount Desert Island High School in Bar Harbor, Maine, on Oct. 22, 2024.
Linda Coan O'Kresik for Education Week
Social Studies 'Can We Trust This Source?' And Other Questions Readers Ask in History
Historical texts require students to weigh authors' bias, context, and audience.
7 min read
Illustration of student reading book with tinted glasses.
Dan Page for Education Week