69ý

Opinion
Science Opinion

Ending the Evolutionary War

By Andrew J. Coulson — March 08, 2005 4 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL
Every aspect of the public school curriculum, not just science education, is inherently political.

The “creation” controversy has splashed down in Gull Lake, Mich. Last spring, according to The Kalamazoo Gazette, a parent complained that two middle school biology teachers were giving the concept of “intelligent design” equal treatment in the classroom with the theory of evolution. The district told them to stop, and both teachers are now crying foul, appealing to the community for help.

Gull Lake parents are divided.

“Intelligent design” contends that the diversity of life on Earth and the complexity of some biological systems could not have arisen by means of evolution. To correct the perceived inadequacy, the theory stipulates that an “intelligent designer” authored the world’s species.

Proponents argue that intelligent design is a serious scientific theory and that, at the very least, its existence should be taught in biology classes. Opponents dismiss it as a superficially secular attempt to inject biblical creationism into public school classrooms—a Lamb of God in sheep’s clothing.

Michigan isn’t alone. All told, roughly 40 states are now embroiled in battles over the teaching of evolution. The American Civil Liberties Union and other groups have filed a lawsuit on behalf of Pennsylvania parents objecting to their school board’s decision to teach intelligent design. As Eugenie C. Scott of the National Center for Science Education told the Gazette, “By lobbying school boards to include creationism or weaken evolution in their science curricula, creationists are politicizing science education.”

But Ms. Scott understates the problem—and misdirects the blame.

Every aspect of the public school curriculum, not just science education, is inherently political. Decisions over what and how to teach are made by elected and appointed government officials. Because there is only one official state organ of education, everyone wants it to conform to his or her own views.

That is impossible.

In a pluralistic society, there are countless different and incompatible worldviews. Our effort to serve that diverse audience through a monolithic school system has not only failed in recent years to forge common ground, it also has bred animosity and discord.

This failure of compelled conformity is no cause for alarm, however. It is unnecessary to force all Americans to accept a single view on the origins of man. While there are certainly issues on which consensus is important in a free society—commitment to the democratic process, respect for the rule of law, and equal rights for all citizens, to name but a few—the origin of humanity is not among them.

Thanks to the separation of church and state, American religious life has avoided most of the political and ideological conflicts that have beset our official state schools.

Nor is it clear that centrally planned public schooling is the best means of nurturing societal agreement in those special areas where it is important. Research shows private school students to be as tolerant and civic-minded as their public school counterparts, and it also shows private schools to be, if anything, more meaningfully integrated than public schools.

Private schools, representing a universe of differing worldviews, coexist as peacefully as private churches. If every family in America had the financial resources to choose the public or private school it preferred, as would be the case under a universal education-tax-credit system, we could enjoy the same harmonious relations in education that we have experienced in the field of religion. Thanks to the separation of church and state, American religious life has avoided most of the political and ideological conflicts that have beset our official state schools.

And honestly, is anyone happy with the way schools currently handle this issue?

Adherents of intelligent design presumably aren’t. They must fight to have their views heard in the public schools, and when they succeed, they immediately face legal challenges. Even if intelligent design prevails in court (as biblical creationism did not), will science teachers present it in a way that will satisfy its advocates?

Adherents of evolution have nothing to cheer about, either. Virtually all biologists see evolution as the fundamental structuring principle of their entire discipline. By contrast, schools often teach it as a brief, isolated unit to avoid controversy.

Tellingly, after generations of public school instruction in the theory of evolution, a recent Gallup poll found that 45 percent of Americans believe humanity is the comparatively recent product of divine creation, while only one-third believe that evolution is a theory well-supported by scientific evidence.

These results must dismay most scientists, and they should cause intelligent-design advocates to question the wisdom of entrusting their own views to the public schools.

Back in Gull Lake, both sides are digging in their heels, and accusations of miseducation and brainwashing have started to fly. So long as we stick with a single official state school system, though, there will always be ideological winners and losers, and such antagonism will remain.

Wouldn’t we all be better off giving school choice a chance instead?

A version of this article appeared in the March 09, 2005 edition of Education Week as Ending the Evolutionary War

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Artificial Intelligence Webinar
AI and Educational Leadership: Driving Innovation and Equity
Discover how to leverage AI to transform teaching, leadership, and administration. Network with experts and learn practical strategies.
Content provided by 
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School Climate & Safety Webinar
Investing in Success: Leading a Culture of Safety and Support
Content provided by 
Assessment K-12 Essentials Forum Making Competency-Based Learning a Reality
Join this free virtual event to hear from educators and experts working to implement competency-based education.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Science 69ý and Writing Like a Scientist
English and science teachers in Missouri middle schools collaborate to help students tackle complex scientific texts.
6 min read
Illustration of magnet attracting letters.
Dan Page for Education Week
Science One Change That Can Get More Girls, 69ý of Color Taking Computer Science
Making computer science classes a graduation requirement can be a powerful strategy.
5 min read
Two teen girls, one is a person of color and the other is white, building something in a science robotics class.
iStock/Getty
Science A Marine Science Program in a Surprising Place Shows 69ý New Career Options
It's hard to find teachers for STEM subjects, but a school system in a landlocked state has found a way to make it work with marine science.
5 min read
Nolden Grohe, 16, feeds exotic fish during Marine Biology class at Central Campus in Des Moines, Iowa, on Sept. 27, 2024.
Nolden Grohe, 16, feeds exotic fish during Marine Biology class at Central Campus in Des Moines, Iowa, on Sept. 27, 2024. The Iowa school system has had a hands-on program for three decades that has introduced students to career possibilities in aquarium science, marine biology, and related fields.
Rachel Mummey for Education Week
Science The Biggest Barriers to STEM Education, According to Educators
Educators share the challenges schools face in teaching STEM.
1 min read
Photograph of a diverse group of elementary school kids, with a white male teacher, working on a robot design in the classroom
E+