Even with the prospect that the federal reading program could lose all its funding, some 6,000 teachers, principals, reading coaches, and district administrators attended the fifth annual National 69传媒 First Conference sponsored by the U.S. Department of Education.
They crowded into dozens of sessions here to learn how to sustain changes they鈥檝e made to instruction, assessment, and professional development to improve student achievement in the subject.
In many of the sessions, conducted by consultants and researchers in the field, deeper implementation of and adherence to the tenets of the 6 1/2- year-old program, with or without federal money, consumed much of the discussion.
鈥淲e are going to figure out how to keep it going,鈥� said Michael Johnson, the principal of Logan Elementary School in Logan, W.Va., which serves 350 students in a rural community. 鈥淚n the beginning, my teachers wanted to hang me [for agreeing to the strict requirements of 69传媒 First], ... but now if you tried to take it away, they鈥檇 fight you.鈥�
Mr. Johnson and several hundred other educators attended a three-hour workshop for sustaining 69传媒 First that was repeated each day of the conference, held July 28-30.
69传媒 coach Debbie Meyer and a cadre of colleagues from the Memphis, Tenn., school district listened attentively throughout the session. Ms. Meyer, a 30-year veteran teacher, said she will postpone retirement if the district figures out how to keep the program going.
Elements of Downfall
House and Senate panels voted last month to zero out funding for 69传媒 First in the federal budget for fiscal 2009, which begins Oct. 1. (鈥� 鈥�69传媒 First鈥� Funds Headed for Extinction鈥�, July 16, 2008.)
The program, which was authorized under the No Child Left Behind Act, had received $1 billion a year from 2002 to 2007 before getting hit with a 61 percent cut in fiscal 2008.
In his subsequent push to eliminate its funding, Rep. David R. Obey, D-Wis., the chairman of the House Appropriations Committee, cited management problems within the program and disappointing results of a preliminary federal evaluation.
Reports released by the Education Department鈥檚 inspector general in 2006 and 2007 suggested some federal officials and contractors involved in implementing the program had conflicts of interest and appeared to favor some commercial products over others.
In addition, an , released May 1 by the department鈥檚 Institute of Education Sciences, concluded that the $1 billion in annual funding had had no effect on students鈥� reading comprehension. The study did not evaluate the effect on overall reading achievement in participating schools. The final report, due this fall, is expected to have additional data comparing 69传媒 First schools with nonparticipating ones in the same districts.
Maintaining the Momentum
Conference attendees generally described the looming federal budget cut as misguided and unfair.
Many state and district leaders shared their own data and anecdotes, which they say show the program is effective.
鈥淟ast year, our school became an average school in our state,鈥� said Wanda Clark, the principal of Kemp Elementary School in Commerce City, Colo., outside Denver. Average is quite a feat for her school, she said, where nearly all the 440 students are considered poor, and more than 70 percent are English-language learners.
The school had the lowest 3rd grade test scores in the state in reading several years ago, Ms. Clark said. 鈥淎t first, our teachers weren鈥檛 sure they could get the kind of improvement that was expected,鈥� she said. 鈥淏ut now, we鈥檝e raised our expectations.鈥�
Colorado is continuing to pay for 46 of its 49 69传媒 First schools, including Kemp Elementary, through the next school year with surplus grant money that was rolled over from previous years, according to Debora Scheffel, who directs the program for the state. Colorado has received some $60 million since the program began.
Ms. Scheffel and other state directors are hoping to mobilize educators in the program to promote inclusion of 69传媒 First principles in the upcoming reauthorization of the NCLB law, such as teaching explicit skills, assessing student progress, and using proven intervention programs for struggling readers.
The state officials also hope to disseminate information on research-based instruction and intervention. They launched the recently and signed up more than 500 attendees at the conference as potential members.
鈥淵es, there are challenges鈥� to keeping the program going and continuing to improve student achievement, Ms. Scheffel said at a state-planning meeting at the conference. 鈥淏ut we need to celebrate the gains and feel like we need to keep the momentum going.鈥�
For many of the participants, that means finding other sources of federal, state, or local money.
It also means following the 69传媒 First framework once the program has ended, said Joseph Conaty, the 69传媒 First director at the federal Education Department. 鈥淢y hope,鈥� he said at the closing session, 鈥渋s that you will continue to do what we all know works.鈥�
