69ý

College & Workforce Readiness

Researchers Connect Lower Achievement, High School Exit Tests

By Debra Viadero — February 01, 2005 3 min read
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

As President Bush promotes his plans for expanding high-stakes testing in the nation’s high schools, a new study has found that states that already have such exams in place have lower graduation rates and college-entrance-exam scores than states that don’t have them.

The study, published Jan. 21 in the electronic journal Education Policy Analysis Archives, zeroes in on 18 states that require high school students to pass an exam in order to graduate. When compared with students in 33 states or territories without such requirements, students in the exit-exam states tended to have both lower scores on the SAT admissions exam and lower graduation rates.

See Also

is available online from the . ()

The research is the latest of a half a dozen or more recent studies that attempt to gauge the impact of the growing push to step up student testing and to hold schools or students accountable for the results.

But much like its predecessors, the new report, by researchers from Ball State University in Muncie, Ind., ran into criticism.

“This study can’t possibly tell you what they’re trying to show,” said Martin Carnoy, a Stanford University researcher whose own work has linked high-stakes testing to student learning gains. Mr. Carnoy, an economics professor, said he faulted the new study for focusing on just one year of student testing and graduation data and using what he sees as a flawed measure of graduation rates.

However, other researchers said the study signals the need for caution at a time when national policymakers are debating how far to extend the testing requirements of the No Child Left Behind Act into high schools. Under the 3-year-old federal law, most states, beginning with the 2005-06 school year, will have to test students at least once in high school to meet the law’s accountability requirements. Mr. Bush has proposed adding two more years of high school testing to that requirement. But the president’s plan does not call for tying those tests to diploma requirements.

Defending the Findings

“Is [this study] worth a big story? Probably not,” said David C. Berliner, an education professor at Arizona State University in Tempe who has also conducted research on high-stakes tests. “Is it worth a warning flag? I’d probably say yes.

“There does seem to be a danger,” he said, “that you could narrow the curriculum and hurt achievement on broader tests like the SAT that measure critical-thinking skills.”

Gregory J. Marchant, the study’s lead author and an educational psychology professor at Ball State, said the study focused on the 2001 SAT scores and 2002 graduation rates as a way to examine the tests’ impact on both ends of the high school population: students who were struggling to stay in school as well as college-bound teenagers.

Previous studies have shown that states with high school exit exams tend to be located in the South and to have high concentrations of poor and minority students—two groups that often score low on standardized tests. So Mr. Marchant and his co-author, Sharon E. Paulson, factored in data on family incomes, racial characteristics, parents’ educational levels, and high school grades in order to compare students from similar backgrounds across states.

To calculate graduation rates, they compared fall 1999 freshman enrollments with the numbers of graduating seniors in 2002. The 64 percent graduation rate they found for exit-exam states was 9 percentage points lower than the rate for other states.

“Any time you raise standards at the high school level, there is potentially no place for some of these kids to go but out,” Mr. Marchant said.

Among the findings for SAT scores, the report shows that high-achieving white students in exit-exam states lagged behind their peers in non-exam states by 13 to 16 percentile points. Those differences decreased a bit, though, when the researchers compared scores for individual students across states rather than clumping together an entire state’s scores.

But Mr. Carnoy of Stanford said the study’s measure of graduation rates failed to account for differences in the size of states’ 9th grade “bulges”—in other words, the upward blip in enrollments that occurs that year as larger numbers of students are held back. Some states, particularly those that ban the practice known as social promotion, are likely to retain more students than others. The study’s method of determining graduation rates also does not account for students who move out of a state.

But Mr. Marchant reasoned that his method is as good as those that rely on schools’ own reports of dropout rates, many of which have recently been shown to be faulty—and even false.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the February 02, 2005 edition of Education Week as Researchers Connect Lower Achievement, High School Exit Tests

Events

This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Special Education Webinar
Don’t Count Them Out: Dyscalculia Support from PreK-Career
Join Dr. Elliott and Dr. Wall as they empower educators to support students with dyscalculia to envision successful careers and leadership roles.
Content provided by 
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
Student Well-Being Webinar
Improve School Culture and Engage 69ý: Archery’s Critical Role in Education
Changing lives one arrow at a time. Find out why administrators and principals are raving about archery in their schools.
Content provided by 
School Climate & Safety Webinar Engaging Every Student: How to Address Absenteeism and Build Belonging
Gain valuable insights and practical solutions to address absenteeism and build a more welcoming and supportive school environment.

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide — elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

College & Workforce Readiness Boys Think School Is a Waste of Time. Career Pathways Prove Them Wrong
Real-world, experiential learning appeals to how boys learn best, educators say.
7 min read
High school student Aaron Bartsch, 17, helps unload tools from a work van before working in a customer’s home as part of an internship with Barkley Heating and Air in Smyrna, Del., on October 15, 2024.
High schooler Aaron Bartsch, 17, helps unload tools from a work van before working in a customer’s home as part of an internship with Barkley Heating and Air in Smyrna, Del., on Oct. 15, 2024. His high school offers career pathways so students can get a taste of real-world, experiential learning.
Michelle Gustafson for Education Week
College & Workforce Readiness The SEL Skills Google, Microsoft, and Other Top Companies Want 69ý to Teach
Senior executives from U.S. companies put a high priority on so-called "soft skills."
8 min read
Diverse male and female characters are assembling cogwheels together at work. Concept of soft skills, work operations, and teamwork productivity. Business workflow as cogwheel mechanism.
Rudzhan Nagiev/iStock
College & Workforce Readiness What Parents Say They Want Their Kids to Get Out of High School
A new poll finds that parents strongly support more options for their kids that might reshape the high school experience.
4 min read
High school student using touchpad on a modern class.
E+
College & Workforce Readiness Most States Will See a Steady Decline in High School Graduates. Here Are the Data
The decline is based largely on population trends.
7 min read
Coleton McLemore is silhouetted against the sky during the Commencement Exercises for the Class of 2020 at Lakeview-Fort Oglethorpe High School's Tommy Cash Stadium on July 31, 2020 in Fort Oglethorpe, Ga.
Coleton McLemore is silhouetted against the sky during the Commencement Exercises for the Class of 2020 at Lakeview-Fort Oglethorpe High School's Tommy Cash Stadium on July 31, 2020 in Fort Oglethorpe, Ga. The country will see a peak in high school graduates in 2025, followed by a steady decline through 2041, affecting most of the nation.
C.B. Schmelter/Chattanooga Times Free Press via AP