69传媒

Special Report
Classroom Technology

Case Study: Clever鈥檚 Troubled Effort to Help 69传媒 Track Ed-Tech Use

By Benjamin Herold 鈥 October 01, 2019 5 min read
BRIC ARCHIVE
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Early in 2018, ed-tech company Clever launched a new product aimed at helping tens of thousands of schools tackle a vexing challenge: determining whether students are actually using the software and learning apps on which the K-12 sector spends billions of dollars each year.

Less than 18 months later, though, it pulled the plug. Clever announced it was 鈥渟unsetting鈥 the effort and moving in a new direction.

What happened? Why did the effort flop? And what does Clever鈥檚 surprise pivot say about how serious schools are about keeping track of all the technology that has flooded public school classrooms?

鈥淲hat we found once we were in market was that it proved to be a nice-to-have more than a must-have for a lot of district leaders,鈥 Dan Carroll, the company鈥檚 co-founder and chief product officer, said in a July interview. 鈥淭hey were excited to try it out, but [tracking ed-tech usage] wasn鈥檛 one of their top three or five priorities for the year.鈥

A Multi-Pronged Problem

That analysis will likely come as a disappointment to those K-12 CTOs and CIOs who describe the opacity around ed-tech usage as a significant鈥攁nd multi-pronged鈥攑roblem.

If schools don鈥檛 know what digital and online learning tools teachers and students actually use, their thinking goes, how can they decide what to purchase and renew? How are they supposed to better focus scarce professional-development resources? How can they determine what ed-tech strategies will actually impact student achievement?

Why Ed Tech Is Not Used and What to Do About It

This special report鈥攖he first in a series of three special reports for the 2019-20 school year that Education Week is producing for K-12 ed-tech leaders鈥攅xamines how schools track tech usage and what steps they should take to make better use of educational technology tools. Read the full report here.

A number of products on the market aim to help. Companies such as LearnPlatform and BrightBytes, for example, offer analytics and dashboards that present information such as how many students log in to various software programs, how much time they spend using them, and what kind of progress they are making.

BrightBytes has tried to highlight the problem of scattershot usage. In 2018, for example, the company released an analysis based on how nearly 400,000 students in 48 districts used 177 different learning apps. It found that the typical district didn鈥檛 use 30 percent of the ed-tech licenses it purchased.

Given such realities, it was significant news when San Francisco-based Clever announced it was launching a new product called Goals. The company had already won the trust of roughly 60,000 schools by offering easy-to-use solutions to mundane problems, such as loading class rosters into learning software and allowing students to access the dozens of online tools with a single username and password.

The company鈥檚 new idea was similar: Give educators and administrators a single place to look across multiple learning tools at two simple metrics: how much time did students spend using each program, and how much progress did they make?

Clever officials were so convinced that districts would find such information valuable they made Goals their first service that schools would have to directly pay to use.

But a year after it was launched, the product had just 50 or so paying customers.

Worse, maintaining the service at even that limited scale proved to be a major time-suck for Clever鈥檚 engineers.

鈥淲e thought it would be very hard and expensive, which certainly proved true,鈥 Carroll said. 鈥淲e just couldn鈥檛 justify it financially.鈥

Unanticipated Complications

One of the school systems that tried Clever Goals, but ended up dropping it, was School District U-46 in Illinois.

It鈥檚 an ongoing challenge to make usage data relevant to both the specific tool being used and the specific way it鈥檚 being used in a given school or classroom, said Matt Raimondi, the district鈥檚 assessment and accountability coordinator, in an email.

Usage data can end up being pretty noisy or misleading. A usage report might show 20 percent of students using software X, and that could actually be 100 percent of the students that are supposed to be using it.鈥

For example, for one service, it might make sense to report how many licenses are actually used. For another, it might be more valuable to report out how much time students spent on-task, using the product. For a third, the most useful information might be the number of lessons or modules each student completes.

Further complicating matters, one school or district might use a tool for core instruction for all students, while another might use the same tool as remediation for a small subset of students.

鈥淯sage data can end up being pretty noisy or misleading in that regard,鈥 Raimondi said. 鈥淎 usage report might show 20 percent of students using software X, and that could actually be 100 percent of the students that are supposed to be using it.鈥

Clever鈥檚 Carroll said that was just one of several issues the company faced with Goals.

Even a single usage metric, such as time-on-task, proved nearly impossible to standardize, he said. How do you capture that with learning tools that require off-line work, for example?

And even when different companies were focused on the same data, he said, they often presented the information in different formats. That meant linking each software program into the Goals dashboard required a custom integration, which proved costly and time-consuming.

But the biggest hurdle by far, Carroll said, wasn鈥檛 technical at all. It was finding ways to help educators and administrators move beyond just looking at usage data to actually doing something useful with the information.

鈥淭hat kind of change management is really a Herculean effort,鈥 he said. 鈥淵ou need cultural buy-in, great training, and time allocated for people to look at the data and talk about it. We kind of underestimated the challenge there.鈥

鈥楶riorities of District Leaders鈥

Paige Kowalski isn鈥檛 one to say 鈥淚 told you so.鈥

But back when Clever Goals was launched, the executive vice president of the nonprofit Data Quality Campaign warned that real data-driven change only comes when educators and administrators get structured opportunities to turn information into action.

鈥淭here鈥檚 this belief out there that if we just get schools one more data point, it will really tell them something,鈥 Kowalski said in an July interview. 鈥淏ut it doesn鈥檛. It just begs more questions. I think that鈥檚 what Clever ran into.鈥

While the company has changed direction and pulled Goals off the market, it isn鈥檛 getting out of tracking ed-tech usage altogether.

Clever is now working on a free analytics tool that seeks to report student and teacher visits to online resources, including the amount of time they spent. The new product is in a testing phase at 300 schools. The company is eyeing early 2020 to make the product more widely available.

Once the tool is up and running, Clever users won鈥檛 be charged extra to use it, Carroll said. The company still isn鈥檛 prepared to offer teachers the kind of time and labor-intensive coaching needed to make usage data valuable for them, he said. So the new product will be focused on helping school and district leaders track aggregate usage and make system-level decisions.

Events

School & District Management Webinar Crafting Outcomes-Based Contracts That Work for Everyone
Discover the power of outcomes-based contracts and how they can drive student achievement.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
Harnessing AI to Address Chronic Absenteeism in 69传媒
Learn how AI can help your district improve student attendance and boost academic outcomes.
Content provided by 
School & District Management Webinar EdMarketer Quick Hit: What鈥檚 Trending among K-12 Leaders?
What issues are keeping K-12 leaders up at night? Join us for EdMarketer Quick Hit: What鈥檚 Trending among K-12 Leaders?

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide 鈥 elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Classroom Technology Opinion Has Technology Been Bad for 69传媒 and Learning?
Education technology is supposed to build knowledge. We need to wrestle with the possibility that it might not.
7 min read
The United States Capitol building as a bookcase filled with red, white, and blue policy books in a Washington DC landscape.
Luca D'Urbino for Education Week
Classroom Technology Opinion Why School Cellphone Bans Are a Bad Idea
We cannot ignore the powerful relationship between students and their phones鈥攁nd what they mean for equity in our most challenged schools.
Brandon Cardet-Hernandez
4 min read
Trendy halftone collage. Hand holding and using cell phone.
Natalya Kosarevich/iStock
Classroom Technology From Our Research Center How Strict Are School Cellphone Policies?
New survey data show that schools are trying a variety of approaches to curb students鈥 cellphone use.
2 min read
Young student using on smartphone in classroom
Leonardo Patrizi/iStock/Getty
Classroom Technology From Our Research Center How 69传媒 Are Dodging Cellphone Restrictions
69传媒鈥 efforts to restrict cellphone use have set up a battle of wits between teachers and students.
1 min read
A ninth grader places her cellphone in to a phone holder as she enters class at Delta High School, Friday, Feb. 23, 2024, in Delta, Utah. At the rural Utah school, there is a strict policy requiring students to check their phones at the door when entering every class. Each classroom has a cellphone storage unit that looks like an over-the-door shoe bag with three dozen smartphone-sized slots.
A 9th grader places her cellphone into a holder as she enters class at Delta High School in Delta, Utah, in February. The rural school has a strict policy requiring students to check their phones at the door when entering every class.
Rick Bowmer/AP