69传媒

Opinion
Teaching Opinion

All Learning, No Questioning: How 69传媒 Smother Curiosity

Traditional policies and practices get in the way of the most effective learning
By Alfie Kohn 鈥 September 23, 2024 5 min read
A teacher erases a large red question mark a student is writing on a whiteboard.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

When Susan Engel, a developmental psychologist at Williams College, decided to spend a few months observing suburban elementary schools, she had a specific goal in mind: to study variations in rates of children鈥檚 curiosity. Which kids asked lots of questions? Which classrooms tended to encourage that? But Engel discovered that it was almost impossible to make valid comparisons because 鈥渢here was such an astonishingly low rate of curiosity in any of the classrooms we visited.鈥

What she kept encountering鈥攄uring that project and since鈥攚ere children who had learned not to bother wondering. If a classmate did volunteer a fascinated observation (鈥淎 bird flew right into my house!鈥) or a question (鈥淲hy would it do that?鈥), it was soon obvious that the teacher would probably offer a perfunctory response and then direct the child back to the planned lesson. In one classroom, Engel heard the teacher say, 鈥淚 can鈥檛 answer questions right now. Now, it鈥檚 time for learning.鈥

For more than half a century, researchers have studied our desire to explore just for the sake of exploring, our itch to make sense of the unexpected. The eminent educator Seymour Sarason argued that education should be dedicated to stimulating the 鈥渋ntellectual curiosity, awe, and wonder that a child possesses when he or she begins schooling.鈥 Or at least try to avoid killing it.

Curiosity is valuable in its own right鈥攁nd not just for children. It鈥檚 a passport to a richer, more fulfilling life. But it also contributes to academic achievement and, more important, to intellectual flourishing. Conservative commentators like to emphasize the capacity to pay attention and delay gratification, but a found that pure curiosity promoted more effective learning regardless of the child鈥檚 level of 鈥渆ffortful control.鈥

In fact, not only was curiosity 鈥渁ssociated with higher academic achievement in all children,鈥 but the researchers discovered to their surprise that its benefits were greatest for kids from low-income families. (Sadly, such students appear disproportionately likely to face a regimented form of instruction in which compliance is prized over discovery.)

Left to their own devices, children will often seek answers to the questions that bubble up in them. But adults can help鈥攍ess by providing answers than by reframing and building on those questions. They can call attention to connections between what different kids are asking. They can assist a community of learners in finding resources and thinking more deeply as they explore.

The researchers discovered to their surprise that [the] benefits [of curiosity] were greatest for kids from low-income families.

How, specifically, should teachers nurture curiosity, taking advantage of what the late psychologist Jerome Bruner once called the 鈥渆nergizing lure of uncertainty鈥?

  • Not just by welcoming students鈥 questions when they diverge from the curriculum but by rethinking the curriculum itself, constructing it with students, not just for them, to address the topics that intrigue them. That includes questions to which the teacher doesn鈥檛 know the answer鈥攁nd, indeed, questions that don鈥檛 have a single right answer.
  • By offering readings that cover complex and controversial topics in genuinely interesting ways. (That鈥檚 very different from depending on cutesy games or apps to tart up unengaging tasks.)
  • By 鈥減riming the pump鈥 when necessary: suggesting questions or offering information that piques students鈥 curiosity about things they haven鈥檛 yet considered.
  • By being curious themselves. confirmed that 鈥渢he teacher鈥檚 own behavior has a powerful effect on a child鈥檚 disposition to explore.鈥 Perhaps curiosity belongs on an administrator鈥檚 list of qualities to look for in job applicants.
  • By being keen to learn how each student鈥檚 mind works. Outstanding teachers tend to do more listening than talking, in part because, as Harvard educator Eleanor Duckworth argued, the more intensely interested a teacher is in a kid鈥檚 thinking, the more interested the kid becomes in her own thinking.
  • By providing students with what psychological theorists call 鈥渁utonomy support"鈥攅ncouraging a sense of self-determination鈥攚hich has been shown to heighten both intrinsic motivation (a concept that鈥檚 similar to curiosity) and the quality of learning.

See Also

A field of lightbulbs, only a couple are lit. Concept idea of light bulb, creative, thinking, motivation, success, and thinking, surreal conceptual art, 3d illustration, painting artwork.
Jorm Sangsorn/iStock + Education Week
Teaching Opinion How to Stifle Student Curiosity in 5 Steps (and What to Do Instead)
Olivia Odileke, July 11, 2024
5 min read

Alas, these recommendations for teachers often run smack into structural constraints: an inflexible schedule that doesn鈥檛 leave time for exploration; a principal who insists on quiet, orderly classrooms; a central office that imposes a standardized curriculum; a school board that cares more about test scores than about meaningful learning.

Other traditional practices have a similar effect. Among the most reliable extinguishers of the flame of curiosity are mandatory homework (making students work a second shift after school), grades and (which signal that success matters more than learning), a preoccupation with rigor (which often elicits anxiety, smothering curiosity), and the use of additional rewards or punishments to enforce this regimen.

Much of the problem comes from construing learning as a list of facts to be memorized or discrete skills to be practiced. This premise tends to promote teacher-centered direct instruction, which is often scripted or otherwise tightly controlled.

A group of University of California, Berkeley researchers found that when young children were shown exactly how to do something, they subsequently engaged in less exploration on their own than those who had received no explicit direction. Likewise, enthusiasm about reading鈥攁 key predictor of proficiency鈥攖ends to be lower when children are subjected to systematic phonics-based instruction rather than a literature-based approach, as Dominic Wyse and Charlotte Hacking explain in their new book . Math teacher and research mathematician Paul Lockhart, meanwhile, wryly described the conventional curriculum in his field as 鈥渁 proven cure for curiosity"鈥攁lso an apt epithet for worksheets.

What Susan Engel discovered to her dismay in the early grades鈥攁 diminished desire to find out鈥攐nly gets worse as kids make their way through traditional schools. Often, we don鈥檛 notice鈥攅ither because, as Engel warns, we assume it鈥檚 enough for a teacher to be a nice, caring person or because we鈥檙e falsely reassured by high-achieving (albeit joyless) students. As education professor Lillian Weber once put it, too many kids start out as exclamation points and question marks, but leave school as plain periods.

Sure, everyone says curiosity is a lovely thing. But are we willing to oppose the traditional practices and policies that fail to nurture and even actively discourage it?

A version of this article appeared in the October 02, 2024 edition of Education Week as All Learning, No Questioning: How 69传媒 Smother Curiosity

Events

School & District Management Webinar Crafting Outcomes-Based Contracts That Work for Everyone
Discover the power of outcomes-based contracts and how they can drive student achievement.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
Harnessing AI to Address Chronic Absenteeism in 69传媒
Learn how AI can help your district improve student attendance and boost academic outcomes.
Content provided by 
School & District Management Webinar EdMarketer Quick Hit: What鈥檚 Trending among K-12 Leaders?
What issues are keeping K-12 leaders up at night? Join us for EdMarketer Quick Hit: What鈥檚 Trending among K-12 Leaders?

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide 鈥 elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Teaching Download How to Build a Classroom That Supports Difficult Conversations (Downloadable)
69传媒 need opportunities to learn how to talk openly and respectfully about divisive topics. Teachers can set students up for success.
1 min read
Word bubbles of different sizes and abstract content arranged in a grid like pattern.
Vanessa Solis/Education Week + iStock
Teaching Opinion 5 Small Classroom Changes for Big Rewards
Most educators know that building relationships is crucial to student learning. Small actions by teachers can help foster them.
10 min read
Conceptual illustration of classroom conversations and fragmented education elements coming together to form a cohesive picture of a book of classroom knowledge.
Sonia Pulido for Education Week
Teaching Opinion 69传媒 Are Often Blamed for Our Foundering Democracy. It鈥檚 Not That Simple
Regardless of who wins the election, teachers must help students see what it means to forge a collective path ahead. Here are three steps.
Nicole Mirra & Antero Garcia
4 min read
Collage art of civics and democracy images.
iStock/Getty + Education Week
Teaching Opinion Post-Election Advice for the Classroom From a Teacher
What educators can say to their students or families if they express concerns or anxiety about election-related classroom discussions.
7 min read
Conceptual illustration of classroom conversations and fragmented education elements coming together to form a cohesive picture of a book of classroom knowledge.
Sonia Pulido for Education Week