69传媒

Opinion
Classroom Technology Opinion

69传媒 Are Easily Duped Online. We Can Teach Them Better

It鈥檚 easy to fall victim to misinformation. These research-backed tips can help
By Sam Wineburg 鈥 October 17, 2023 4 min read
Conceptual illustration of young character looking through the magnifying glass at open laptop Search bar
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

Kyle Smith has been teaching at Superior High School, perched on the Wisconsin side of Lake Superior, for the past 27 years. Last year, he asked his students to examine two websites.

runs campaigns like Veggies Early & Often that promote nutrition and healthy eating to school-aged children. (ILSI) also offers nutrition information but has minimized the harmful effects of tobacco and cast doubt on guidelines that tell people to consume less sugar. characterize ILSI as 鈥渓ittle more than a front group advancing the interest of the 400 corporate members that provides its $17 million budget,鈥 according to The New York Times.

Nearly two-thirds of Smith鈥檚 students rated ILSI as the more credible of the two sites, he later told me over email. These students have been on the internet practically since birth. So why did they get duped?

They aren鈥檛 alone. In 2019, my research team at Stanford 3,446 high school students by providing an internet connection and having them solve six tasks. On one task, they watched a video on social media that allegedly showed ballot stuffing in the 2016 Democratic primaries. A few keywords in their browsers would have led to from Snopes and the BBC showing the video to be from the 2016 Russian elections. Only three students鈥攍ess than one-tenth of 1 percent鈥攖raced the clip back to Russia.

States have begun to wake up to the threat posed by digital illiteracy. is the latest to pass legislation requiring online literacy in the curriculum. Such mandates couldn鈥檛 have come sooner.

A few years ago, you could spot sketchy content by its telltale misspellings, malapropisms, and tortured sentences鈥攖he ham-handed attempts by foreign governments to spread disinformation. Not anymore.

Today, the tools of generative AI allow bad actors to mass produce fraudulent content in crystalline prose. , a company that tracks misinformation and assigns credibility ratings to news outlets, has located 510 news sites created by AI tools as of Oct. 10. Place your bets on that number mushrooming in the pre-election days to come.

How should we prepare Kyle Smith鈥檚 students鈥攁ctually, how should all of us prepare鈥攖o meet this onslaught? One answer, intoned like a Greek chorus, is to 鈥渢each critical thinking.鈥 Smith鈥檚 students, however, didn鈥檛 need to do more thinking. They needed to do less.

Smith鈥檚 students, however, didn鈥檛 need to do more thinking. They needed to do less.

Landing on ILSI, students were impressed because, as they put it, the organization 鈥渟hows all of the science and numbers of food equity.鈥 They recognized its dot-org domain and its tax-exempt status, both of which, they believed, added to the legitimacy of the site. They were swayed by the reports under its science and research tab and commented favorably on the organization鈥檚 international reach, with 鈥13 entities across the globe鈥 that 鈥渦se research from all over the world,鈥 making it 鈥渕ore able to synthesize information regarding nutrition.鈥

Each moment students spent delving into this polished site鈥攑ressing links, reading the About page, scrolling through its Ph.D.-studded advisory board with representatives from esteemed universities鈥攇ave the organization鈥檚 PR impresarios more time to work their magic.

Imagine, however, a fundamentally different approach. Before rushing headlong into a site, students could have taken a deep breath and asked themselves a preliminary question: Do I really know what I鈥檓 looking at? Is this truly the website of a credible scientific organization?

Thinking you can tell what something is by looking at it plays into the swindler鈥檚 hand. Unless you bring extensive background knowledge to a topic, it鈥檚 easy to fall victim to crafty information manipulation. When award-winning judge sites outside their expertise, they, too, get taken in. No matter how thoroughly you scour ILSI鈥檚 website, you鈥檇 never learn that Mars, maker of M&M鈥檚 and Skittles, cut ties with the group because they didn鈥檛 or that in 2021, Coca-Cola abandoned ship as well.

You discover these crucial pieces of context only by getting off the site and consulting the internet, which is precisely how vet unfamiliar sources. To gain quick context, these professionals open new tabs and use the internet to check the internet, a process called .

It is not something students spontaneously do. But they can be taught. In a conducted by my research team in the Lincoln, Neb., public schools, students whose regular teachers taught them to read laterally nearly doubled their ability to make wise choices compared with peers in regular classrooms. In a , students showed a sixfold increase in use of fact-checking techniques like lateral reading and a fivefold increase in citations of appropriate context after only seven hours of instruction. Similar results have been obtained by researchers working in Sweden, Germany, and Italy.

No one is immune to the slippery wiles plied by today鈥檚 digital rogues. It鈥檚 sheer hubris to think we鈥檙e smart enough to outsmart the web, relying on knowledge from 9th grade biology to evaluate scientific reports on virology or an introductory statistics class to assess multiple-parameter data from the North Greenland Ice Core Project. Instead of thinking we possess the tools needed to suss out a cloaked site by dissecting its prose or locating flaws in its research reports, the act of leaving a site to leverage the power of the internet wrests control from its designers and puts it back where it belongs.

In our own hands.

Related Tags:

A version of this article appeared in the November 01, 2023 edition of Education Week as 69传媒 Are Easily Duped Online. We Can Teach Them Better

Events

School & District Management Webinar Crafting Outcomes-Based Contracts That Work for Everyone
Discover the power of outcomes-based contracts and how they can drive student achievement.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
Harnessing AI to Address Chronic Absenteeism in 69传媒
Learn how AI can help your district improve student attendance and boost academic outcomes.
Content provided by 
School & District Management Webinar EdMarketer Quick Hit: What鈥檚 Trending among K-12 Leaders?
What issues are keeping K-12 leaders up at night? Join us for EdMarketer Quick Hit: What鈥檚 Trending among K-12 Leaders?

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide 鈥 elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Classroom Technology Opinion Has Technology Been Bad for 69传媒 and Learning?
Education technology is supposed to build knowledge. We need to wrestle with the possibility that it might not.
7 min read
The United States Capitol building as a bookcase filled with red, white, and blue policy books in a Washington DC landscape.
Luca D'Urbino for Education Week
Classroom Technology Opinion Why School Cellphone Bans Are a Bad Idea
We cannot ignore the powerful relationship between students and their phones鈥攁nd what they mean for equity in our most challenged schools.
Brandon Cardet-Hernandez
4 min read
Trendy halftone collage. Hand holding and using cell phone.
Natalya Kosarevich/iStock
Classroom Technology From Our Research Center How Strict Are School Cellphone Policies?
New survey data show that schools are trying a variety of approaches to curb students鈥 cellphone use.
2 min read
Young student using on smartphone in classroom
Leonardo Patrizi/iStock/Getty
Classroom Technology From Our Research Center How 69传媒 Are Dodging Cellphone Restrictions
69传媒鈥 efforts to restrict cellphone use have set up a battle of wits between teachers and students.
1 min read
A ninth grader places her cellphone in to a phone holder as she enters class at Delta High School, Friday, Feb. 23, 2024, in Delta, Utah. At the rural Utah school, there is a strict policy requiring students to check their phones at the door when entering every class. Each classroom has a cellphone storage unit that looks like an over-the-door shoe bag with three dozen smartphone-sized slots.
A 9th grader places her cellphone into a holder as she enters class at Delta High School in Delta, Utah, in February. The rural school has a strict policy requiring students to check their phones at the door when entering every class.
Rick Bowmer/AP