69传媒

Opinion
Social Studies Opinion

How To Fix the Shockingly Low NAEP History and Civic Scores

Our response to these troubling scores will demand a focus on reading
By Susan Pimentel 鈥 May 03, 2023 5 min read
Illustration of a book, a globe, and a compass.
  • Save to favorites
  • Print
Email Copy URL

The latest 鈥渘ation鈥檚 report card鈥 is grim: Just 13 percent of 8th graders hit the 鈥減roficient鈥 mark in U.S. history, and 22 percent hit the goal in civics. This represents a 2-point drop in civics from 2018, the first decrease since testing on the subject began 24 years ago. History results are even more dire: The average score dropped 5 points, representing a significant downward trajectory that started in 1994. Once we鈥檝e picked our jaws up off the floor, we have to ask, what do we do?

While we need a range of solutions, including carving out more time for high-quality civics and history instruction beginning in elementary school, we can鈥檛 ignore the role reading plays. released in the fall of 2022 showed less than a third of 8th graders are performing at the NAEP proficient level.

It all fits. 69传媒 can鈥檛 develop content knowledge if they can鈥檛 read the material in history and civics classes (or a general social studies course).

See Also

Special Report v39 15 Get69传媒Right cover
Getty
69传媒 & Literacy Opinion Why Doesn't Every Teacher Know the Research on 69传媒 Instruction?
Susan Pimentel, October 26, 2018
5 min read

We have to attack the problem in two ways鈥攕hifting what happens in English class and changing how we teach civics and history. We need to include more civics and history in literacy lessons and add more deliberate literacy instruction in civics and history.

Doing this is imperative. Over a quarter century of research is emphatic: The more knowledge students have about the world, the better their reading comprehension is. The better they read, the better able they are to access more complex and compelling reading material and build more knowledge to become even better readers. 69传媒 ability and building knowledge are mutually supportive.

For starters, English class should include more nonfiction. Educational standards adopted by most states, which I worked with a team of educators to write, call for that. But is it happening? How many curricular programs regularly focus time and attention on content-rich texts? How many cultivate students鈥 literacy and knowledge bases simultaneously?

Too few.

Many programs serve up a scattershot approach, toggling quickly between a range of disconnected topics, often weighted toward fiction鈥攚hich hardly adds up to building a coherent body of knowledge.

Of course, improving student achievement in history and civics shouldn鈥檛 be鈥攃an鈥檛 be鈥攖he sole responsibility of a school鈥檚 English department if students are going to make genuine headway.

In my more than a decade of training teachers around the nation on college- and career-readiness standards in English/language arts and literacy, I often hear complaints from social studies (and other content-area) teachers that students can鈥檛 access their textbooks鈥攖oo complex, they say. Teachers fret they have no choice but to lecture, convey the textbook鈥檚 important ideas through slides, and hope what they say sticks.

While history and civics teachers can certainly benefit from more literacy training, most already have what it takes to adopt a literacy-rich approach to their content teaching.

My middle school granddaughter recently confessed to loathing her history class. I took a deep breath and looked at her textbook and class notes before launching into my appeal on history鈥檚 behalf. What I found, both in the textbook and notes (one a recitation of the other) was dull. Both were full of stats but short on ideas or any discussion of the larger consequences. I couldn鈥檛 tell how events or people connected or what lessons I was meant to learn. Neither offered additional resources to flesh out my understanding, connect what happened then to what鈥檚 happening now, or address the age-old question, 鈥淲hy do I even need to learn this?鈥

There鈥檚 a better way. While history and civics teachers can certainly benefit from more literacy training, most already have what it takes to adopt a literacy-rich approach to their content teaching. It is vital that attending to students鈥 reading skills be designed to complement the specific content demands of the discipline, not replace them.

I鈥檝e seen this in action. Eighth grade classrooms in districts as varied as Charlotte, N.C.; Denver; Oakland, Calif.; and New York City have used a literacy-rich history/civics lesson on and the nation鈥檚 broader ideals of equality and freedom. I鈥檝e helped teach the approach to scores of adult educators over the past four years, and here鈥檚 how it works: 69传媒 first watch a related video of President Abraham Lincoln meeting with soldiers and study Civil War photographs. Next, they read conceptually related passages, tailored to a range of student levels to provide context and build their knowledge.

The previously unfamiliar quickly becomes familiar: 69传媒 are prepared to dig deeply into the meaning and messages of the Gettysburg Address鈥攖hen and now.

Feedback from teachers has been instantaneous and positive. They report leaving the training with ready-to-use instructional activities that will engage their learners in high levels of content and language development. 鈥淚 particularly like the scaffolding of the Gettysburg Address. I never analyzed it that way before and I believe that these strategies would work with other historical documents as well,鈥 one trainee told me. 鈥淭hese activities will make the classes dynamic and support deep learning.鈥

It鈥檚 not a zero-sum game: Both content areas鈥攈istory/civics and literacy鈥攇ain. Taking this literacy-rich approach to history/civics instruction not only makes students more informed citizens but also makes them better readers. And it can go a long way toward addressing the urgent crisis before us. The 8th graders who took these tests last year are in high school today. Unless we do something to grab their interest and advance their reading competence, they will soon enter college and the workforce with extremely limited knowledge about American democracy and our history. That鈥檚 a grave threat to our nation.

This dovetails with the threat inherent in students鈥 poor reading scores. That threatens their futures鈥攆utures in which they will be expected to independently and confidently pick through staggering amounts of information. We can tackle these twin problems by acknowledging literacy and civics are tightly intertwined, shifting instruction to reflect that reality, and providing all students with the intellectual stimulation they crave and the learning opportunities they so desperately need.

See Also

Photo of students taking exam on laptops.
iStock / Getty Images Plus

A version of this article appeared in the May 17, 2023 edition of Education Week as How 69传媒 Can Help Fix Declines in History and Civics Score

Events

School & District Management Webinar Crafting Outcomes-Based Contracts That Work for Everyone
Discover the power of outcomes-based contracts and how they can drive student achievement.
This content is provided by our sponsor. It is not written by and does not necessarily reflect the views of Education Week's editorial staff.
Sponsor
School & District Management Webinar
Harnessing AI to Address Chronic Absenteeism in 69传媒
Learn how AI can help your district improve student attendance and boost academic outcomes.
Content provided by 
School & District Management Webinar EdMarketer Quick Hit: What鈥檚 Trending among K-12 Leaders?
What issues are keeping K-12 leaders up at night? Join us for EdMarketer Quick Hit: What鈥檚 Trending among K-12 Leaders?

EdWeek Top School Jobs

Teacher Jobs
Search over ten thousand teaching jobs nationwide 鈥 elementary, middle, high school and more.
Principal Jobs
Find hundreds of jobs for principals, assistant principals, and other school leadership roles.
Administrator Jobs
Over a thousand district-level jobs: superintendents, directors, more.
Support Staff Jobs
Search thousands of jobs, from paraprofessionals to counselors and more.

Read Next

Social Studies 'If We Don鈥檛 Vote, Nothing Is Going to Change': First-Time Voters Report Back
69传媒 at this Wyoming high school share their experience of voting for the first time.
6 min read
Arapahoe Charter School seniors Alissah C'Hair, Kenya Rhodes, Dontae Antelope, Esperanza Sittingeagle, Zona Roskowske, and Kieden Birdshead stand for a group photo after casting their votes on Nov. 5, 2024, in Arapahoe, Wy.
Arapahoe Charter School seniors Alissah C'Hair, Kenya Rhodes, Dontae Antelope, Esperanza Sittingeagle, Zona Roskowske, and Kieden Birdshead stand for a group photo after casting their votes on Nov. 5, 2024, in Arapahoe, Wy.
Carl Cote for Education Week
Social Studies Download What Is Social Studies Literacy? How Educators In the Field Teach 69传媒
The sources students consult, the kinds of arguments they make, differ from history to economics to geography.
1 min read
Image of a bookshelf.
Luoman/E+
Social Studies Inside the Class Where 69传媒 Talk About Abortion, Trump v. Harris, and More
A Maine high school has piloted a new class called Election Year, where students dive deep into campaign politics.
8 min read
EdTech Megan Leddy holds up her laptop to show an Electoral College map to students Sabrina Conary and Asher Clark during a discussion in the Election Year course at Mount Desert Island High School in Bar Harbor, Maine, on Oct. 22, 2024.
Teaching assistant Megan Leddy holds up her laptop to show an Electoral College map to students Sabrina Conary and Asher Clark during a discussion in the Election Year course at Mount Desert Island High School in Bar Harbor, Maine, on Oct. 22, 2024.
Linda Coan O'Kresik for Education Week
Social Studies 'Can We Trust This Source?' And Other Questions Readers Ask in History
Historical texts require students to weigh authors' bias, context, and audience.
7 min read
Illustration of student reading book with tinted glasses.
Dan Page for Education Week